Laser vs. Inkjet Printer?
Until you open up the hood of a desktop printer, you may not know what technology has been included, how many inkjet or toner cartridges it has or what the exact color makeup is inside.
Inkjet printers, i.e. HP, Epson, Canon and Brother, come in many styles when it comes to number of colors and number of cartridges. As inkjet printers are most often used for photo printing and for printing on a multitude of substrate types (i.e. plain paper, photo papers & specialty which includes labels, films, iron-on transfer, etc.), manufacturers utilize even more colors to produce a wider color gamut. Until you open up the hood, you may not know how many cartridges it has or what the exact color makeup is inside. Unfortunately laser printers are very limited in what they can print on and be prepared for the high price for color laser toner cartridges. Unfortunately 1/3 of laser printers are bad for your health based on several University studies – for more information see below. As a result, more and more businesses owners have switched to Inkjet printers.
Laser printers have fairly simple printing systems that generally use either one or four toner cartridges. If it is just one, that means it is a monochrome printer and requires only black toner. If there are four laser printer cartridges, each will hold one of the four standard colors- cyan, magenta, yellow and black. Inkjet printers on the other hand are most often used for photo printing and for printing on a multitude of substrate types (i.e. plain paper, photo papers & specialty which includes labels, films, iron-on transfer, etc.), manufacturers utilize even more colors to produce a wider color gamut.
Ink Cartridges. Over the years, the standard inkjet printer system that required only two cartridges has expanded up to eight cartridges for some consumer inkjet printer models. Typically the fewer the cartridges, the less precise the quality and color range. All newer inkjet printer models are capable of producing solid text and clear graphics; most support photo and wireless printing.
This is the original system used in consumer inkjet printers and is still found with low-end HP and Canon product offerings that continue to be sold today, but often spruced up a bit with web enabled features, etc.
One cartridge will hold the black ink and the other consists of yellow, magenta and cyan ink. For inkjet printer models geared toward photos, optional cartridges were available that held other colors, typically light cyan and light magenta or gray ink. The reason for these extra cartridges that can be installed in lieu of the primary cartridges is to create more accurate photos. Cost of ownership is low if only used for low printing volumes (i.e. 1-15 pages per week, maximum). Ink maintenance routines are extremely light on these models as compared to 4 thru 8 ink cartridge equipped printers which perform much more aggressive ‘nozzle/head cleaning’ routines – this significantly helps reduce ink costs due to maintenance. Printer power may be turned off each day without any significant impact to ink cost.
Just like color laser printers, some inkjet printers have four inkjet cartridges that hold cyan, magenta, yellow and black ink. The benefit of this system is that each color can be replaced separately as it runs out, unlike the two-cartridge system. These cartridges are often larger as well, so they don’t need to be replaced as often. Cost of ownership is generally low if used for frequent printing (small print jobs 3-5 times a week; ~15-25 pages minimum to see a benefit over 2 ink cartridge models). This also assumes that printer power is left ON (very important for most HP & Canon consumer inkjet printers).
Multiple cartridges (Five or Six Cartridges).
Machines that use five or six cartridges are generally designed specifically for photo printing.
Along with the four standard colors, which are often referred to simply as CMYK, either light or photo cyan and magenta cartridges may be needed. The extra hues help to saturate the areas of a print that would require half-toning, which basically means using less Cyan or Magenta ink to create lighter colors. The reason Yellow doesn’t come in “light” form is because our eyes cannot recognize flaws in the color yellow like we can cyan and magenta. However, more and more printer models now offer 5 cartridges, with the 5th cartridge being photo black. Photo Black (BK) is used for improving the look of photographic prints, or not exactly 100% black-based plain paper documents. The photo black also helps smooth out transitions (i.e. gradients) in both photos and black and white-based documents.
Cost of ownership is generally low if used for frequent printing (small print jobs 3-5 times a week; ~25-50 pages minimum to see a benefit over 2 ink cartridge models). This also assumes that printer power is left ON (very important for most HP & Canon consumer inkjet printers). NOTE: For comparison purposes, a typical 4×6″ color photo uses roughly 3 times more ink than a standard plain paper page (@22% ISO 24712 color density).
Eight (or more) Cartridges.
The only people likely to really NEED an inkjet printer that uses eight or more cartridges are professional photographers or designers.
These machines are slightly more expensive, as is the maintenance for them. The Canon i9900, for instance, has eight cartridges: CMYK, Photo cyan, Photo magenta, Red and Green. The two new colors printers like this introduce, red and green, expand the color gamut immensely, creating flawless images that are extremely true-to-life, but the cost of replacing so many cartridges is often prohibitive for the average person.
Inkjet printers are known for the quality of photos and images they deliver, and the different levels of quality that can be achieved are partially based on the colors available in the cartridge system. The basic two or four-cartridge systems should be sufficient for most people, but photographers or photo enthusiasts may want to consider the larger cartridge systems with more colors. Those who are considering the upgrade should first factor in the extra ink costs, however, to determine if it is really worth it. Cost of ownership is considered medium if used for average photo print jobs (i.e. 5-10 photos A3/A4 size prints/week…..for higher volume runs it is recommended to send out to a commercial print service). See below. It is suggested to leave printer power ON to help reduce ink maintenance and servicing routines which consume ink during each power cycle.
Cost of Printing Considerations
Have you ever calculated the total cost of printing for your business, home business and/or for personal use? Did you buy the cheapest printer in the store? Should you get inkjet or laser? Here’s a scary statistic. If you work a 50 hour week, between half an hour and 90 minutes of the time you spend earning money goes on covering the cost of business-related printing materials. That’s between 1% and 3% of your revenue according to research conducted by large printer manufacturers. One of the first questions you’ll need to answer when buying a new printer is laser vs inkjet.
In the past, the answer was easy. Lasers for black and white and inkjets for color. When color laser printers hit the market they were very expensive but they’re now affordable (i.e. start at $280 USD). And so the gap between the two technologies has narrowed, however be prepared….the high price for color laser toner cartridges can be very hard to swallow and will surely put a dent into your wallet. More and more businesses owners have moved over to Inkjet printers as a result (i.e. HP OfficeJet, OfficeJet Pro & Epson WorkForce series printer models). However, while the up-front cost can be an immediately painful wound to your bank balance it’s the slow bleed that most small business don’t monitor or manage that really causes the pain. How do you consider this when buying your new printer?
- Measure how much you print per month. You can do this by either counting the reams or pages of paper manually or using some print management software.
- Don’t just look at the printer cost, check the consumables. Grab the replacement cartridges for the printers you’re considering and pay close attention. Most will be rated for a certain number of pages. If a replacement cartridge costs $50 but can print 1,000 pages it’s better value than a $25 cartridge that’s rated for 400 pages.
- Paper is not the big cost. Sure, be frugal and shop around for your paper, but ink consumables almost always cost more than paper. Typical consumables cost breakdown: ~15% for paper on average (i.e. 2% for plain paper vs. 20% for specialty photo papers, depending on your requirements) and ~85% for ink cartridges & maintenance.
Laser Printer Danger
Professor Lidia Morawska from Queensland University of Technology’s International Laboratory for Air Quality and Health has details on dangerous emissions from common laser printers. Her earlier finding was that almost 1/3 of popular laser printers emitted large numbers of ultrafine particles and VOCs (volatile organic compounds which are harmful to the environment and your health). “In the printing process, toner is melted and when it is hot, certain compounds evaporate and those vapours then nucleate or condense in the air, forming ultrafine particles,” she said. You can try to avoid using laser printers at home by sticking to inkjet printers or safer printers on their list. Also ensure ventilation is good around laser printers and that they are turned off when not needed.
Counterfeit inkjet cartridges warning!
"Clone" & "compatible" cartridges are made to look incredibly similar to OEM cartridges, fooling you into thinking you are getting a great value product and getting the same quality as a genuine cartridge. These manufacturers are illegally copying the design, parts and even the patents of the original manufacturer – clear violations of manufacturer’s intellectual property (IP) rights. In the industry these types of products are commonly referred to as ‘infringing compatibles’. US Customs and Border Protection officers, via official GEO (general exclusion orders) issued by US district courts, routinely stop these shipments at port of entry or within Amazon warehouses where they are commonly transferred and/or stored. The frequency of these illegal product raids currently occurs two to three times a month.
Clones are exact copies of the original HP, Canon, Epson or Brother cartridge and typically violate Original Equipment Manufacturer’s Intellectual Property (OEM IP). These cartridges usually cannot be legally sold in the USA (though many on-line resellers seem to try on a monthly basis via Amazon). Most, if not all, are made in China. Many industry analysts and product reviewers refer to these cartridges as ‘infringing clones’. In recent years, HP, Canon, Epson and Brother have obtained countless General Exclusion Orders (GEO) which permit customs to conduct raids on warehouses, shipments and Amazon fulfillment centers where infringing clones are being stored & sold.
Compatibles are knock-offs made from scratch, usually claiming to be protected under the manufacturers own IP, but all too often (in recent years) they have been found to violate Original Equipment Manufacturer’s Intellectual Property (OEM IP) as select internal parts are used/replaced. Most, if not all, are made in China. OEM investigations have found many of these ‘compatibles’ are actually ‘infringing clones’. There is a big grey area between marketing messages related to ‘clones’ and ‘compatibles’ and that is why all of the OEMs are taking so many companies & re-sellers to court on a regular basis now.
Remanufactured cartridges are original cartridges which have been used by US customers once or twice, collected via recycling centers, and then refurbished (i.e. cleaned, refilled and OEM trademark logo is removed) and had a new replacement smart chip added. Typically these do not violate IP. Most remans are made in USA and will clearly state ‘Remanufactured’ at point of sale and/or on ink packaging.
Genuine ink cartridges are manufactured by the Original Equipment Manufacturers (i.e. HP, Canon, Epson and Brother). These are also referred to as Original Ink Cartridges.
You may find it hard to tell the difference as some counterfeit cartridges can be made to look incredibly similar to the real deal. The other downside is that these cartridges are illegal to sell and produce, which no one wants to get involved with ideally.
If your ink cartridge suffered an electronic or physical failure may we suggest you try a remanufactured ink cartridge from our on-line web site. Our ink cartridges have a high reliability rating, come with a 1-year warranty and we provide free shipping for all orders above $30 (USA residents only).